Mulch Type | Availability | Characteristics |
Bark chips | Purchase in bags at garden centers | Weed-free; long-lasting; moderately good at smothering small weeds; not as good at conserving moisture as most other mulches; attractive to some people |
Compost | Make your own, get free from yard waste sites, or buy at garden centers | Nutrient-rich; usually weed-free; prevents disease; excellent mulch for vegetable beds |
Grass clippings | Free whenever you or your neighbors mow; do not use clippings from lawns treated with weedkillers | Usually weed-free; excellent at smothering weeds; thick layers of fresh clippings may heat up, so apply only 1/2-inch thick and not near stems of young plants |
Hay | Cut your own, collect along roadsides, or buy in bales | May contain weed seeds; good at smothering weeds; salt hay is gathered in marshes and will not bring in weeds |
Hulls and shells | Bagged for purchase, perhaps free where grown or processed | Includes hulls and shells of peanuts, buckwheat, cocoa bean and rice; weed-free; fairly rich in nutrients; best for smothering weed seedlings or keeping weeds out of weed-free areas; longevity varies |
Leaves | Free for the raking; from neighbors also | Weed-free except for occasional tree seeds; good at smothering weeds; hold in moisture very well; shred with lawnmower to prevent them from blowing away |
Pine needles | Rake your own (although your pines would like them left in place); can be bought in some areas | Weed-free; long-lasting; moderately good at smothering weeds; pretty; don’t worry about alleged pH effects |
Sawdust | Usually free, but can be purchased by the truckload | Weed-free; long-lasting; good at smothering weed seedlings; avoid sawdust from pressure-treated or painted wood |
Seaweed | Often collected or dumped for free | Weed-free; nutrient-rich; not long-lasting; excellent at smothering weeds when fresh |
Stone | Usually purchased; various rocks in various colors | Weed-free and essentially nutrient-free; mostly for paths, except perhaps around cactuses and other succulents; lasts almost forever but needs periodic weeding by raking or plucking |
Straw | Purchase baled | Should be weed-free; replenish annually; very good at smothering weeds and holding soil moisture |
Wood chips | Purchase or obtain free by truckload | Weed-free; moderately long-lasting; good at smothering weeds |
Learn all about using natural, weed-free garden techniques that will save you time and labor and create a healthier, thriving garden in Weedless Gardening.